Deviations will be added to the No Good collection if I think they are not art.

Deviations will be faved and added to the Quality Artwork collection if I like them and feel they are worthy of showcasing.

I will try my best to leave comments with constructive criticism on all pieces that I fav or add to a collection.

Please keep in mind that constructive criticism does not equate to lavishing praise when it is unwarranted. If I feel that your work warrants no praise, it shall receive none. This site has been tainted by not only the endless torrents of non-art images, but also the complete lack of serious criticism. An artist should be prepared for criticism when uploading to this site. Ask yourself, would the people on CGTalk and ConceptArt.org tear this apart? Will my feelings be hurt if that is the case? If your answer to both of these questions is "yes", then you should practise more before posting to this site as well.

That is not to say I condone flaming. I will never post a comment that sounds like this: "u suck and you will nevar be good at art so don't post your ugly crap here u retard". Flaming is an attack on a person. I only aim to provide feedback on a particular piece.

If you feel that I have not given you constructive criticism, state this when replying to my comments and I will try to provide you with useful feedback. Again, this will not necessarily include praise if none is warranted.

At the same time, if you will not accept my critique because you believe that my level of artistic skill is not high enough to allow me the authority to hand out critique, I ask you simply to refer to the following quote:

"It doesn't take a chef to know that the soup is too salty."

In other words, I have functional eyes. It doesn't take a world-class artist to see that a poorly-made image is poorly made.

Some of my policies include:
1. Never adding pieces in Scraps to my No Good gallery. Scraps is an acceptable place to put garbage. Anything that is currently in my No Good collection that is also in Scraps was moved there after the fact by the artist.

2. Always reading artists' comments.

3. In general, only selecting one particularly bad piece from an offender's gallery to add to my No Good collection. One piece should be enough to convey the intended message.

4. Giving critique that is only directed at the piece in question. Comments should never be a form of personal attack.

5. I will try my best to oblige all critique requests. Since I am very busy in my life outside the internet, I cannot always guarantee that these will come in a prompt manner.